The Noble Amateur
This is an idea that was brought to my attention via a class I am taking on the media, specifically online, and its effects on society.
(SO cool, I know...Butler baby)
There is this guy... named Andrew Keen...who wrote a book... called The Cult of the Amateur from which we read an excerpt about his thoughts on "The Noble Amateur".
In the excerpt he says, in a nutshell, that the amateurs (you and I) are getting online to blog, tweet, facebook, and are crampin' the experts' (Andrew Keen) style. He sees our online posts as "second hand information" that are purely "mediocre" and making "higher education lose its value." As a new blogger, I am offended.
1. How is Andrew Keen any better than me? Because he has a piece of paper that deems him a scholar?
2. Since when was America based around such elitist ideals?
![]() |
| This is America the FREE: Free to be amateurs! |
Now, I pose this thought for Keen:
If sites such as Wikipedia and social networks such as facebook are ruining the tradition of the scholar and spreading lies, then why are they so successful? Why have they created an extreme cultural shift? Don't you think the good, honest, people of America would see through theses sites if they were that transparent?
Bringing this back to the music industry...what is Keen suggesting about all the successful musical artists that have gained recognition which otherwise would have been unavailable without tools such as blogs and YouTube?
The band I used to work for, WALK THE MOON, is now one the most talked about up-and-coming bands of 2011 simply because of a single blog post calling all A&R reipresetives to see their show at a small venue in New York City.
..and WALK THE MOON are no amateurs.
The frontman studied theory in college, arranges strings for other musicians on the side, and has the talent to make a huge impact on the music industry.
It is these instances that make me question Keen's attitude towards the amateur.
Is he really trying to propose that our society has a problem and needs to stop referencing Wikipeidia?
Or is he just pissed and bitter that us commoners no longer have to wait for his next appearance on a History Channel special to tell us what's what?
Think about it.
KGC












